Football manager attribute weighting. So use use all relevant attributes weighted.
● Football manager attribute weighting Recommended Posts Jun 20, 2016 · The game has an attribute weighting system based on positions. For a DC position, Decision is the highest, next is Marking & Position, next is Acceleration - Agility Jan 7, 2022 · I. Attributes (ratings) for players are split into three main groups, each playing an important role in determining a player’s overall ability and fit for specific positions in your team: Technical Attributes: These are about a player’s skills with the ball, like passing, shooting, and dribbling. Once you have copied the file to the correct location you Jan 18, 2022 · The result is that attribute weights have direct impact in the Chinese I copied the file into the ratings folder in the C drive. conversely abou diaby, someone with a decent premier league CA, is actually highly effective because his physical attributes are so good. 0. yatahaze. Consider the captain's Consistency, Will to win (Determination), Big Match, Loyalty (For the Fans) and Pressure attributes as giving a sort of weighted bonus to the rest of the team. Natural fitness and leadership also have zero weighting by default Reply reply Top 1% Rank by size . Like for example: on the default filters, my Pizzi is way higher rated than my Reinier - however in-game, Reinier performs way better (more goals, assists, 4 days ago · Football Manager Player Attributes Types. preferable attribute weighting May 8, 2011 · Attribute Weighting Training Schedules I took the weighted attributes calculated in this thread ( C:\Users\YourPC\Documents\Sports Interactive\Football Manager 2011\schedules), inside the game go to training, click Manage Schedules, Import, then select AttributeWeighted Training. Football Manager Feature Requests ; Reviewed ; Attribute Weight for roles Attribute Weight for roles. As hidden attributes, I mean specifically Dirtiness, Versatility, Injury Proneness, Consistency and Important Matches. 0 RPM (aka Blue DM). The role in question is CM-S (Central Midfielder - Support), and from Jan 5, 2021 · The Definitive Guide to Current Ability in Football Manager. Z. Each attribute is given a weighting/ratio depending on the position of a player. The most interesting finding to me is that you can "cheat" a player's CA-PA ratio if you have Dec 17, 2017 · In a perfect world that weighting would reflect exactly how important the attribute was within the ME and every attribute would have a 100% balanced weighting. Posted Nov 13, 2023. Keep in mind that not everything might translate to other tactics, but it's only natural that a good part of it actually does. But then, when you use these datas to weight the actual raw attributes of a player, you dont really use these weight, but you divide them by 5 and then add 1 to get the weight which will be then multiplied by the raw attribute. 1 2 3 NEXT. 7/20 or 13/20) would correspondence with a scale of Very Poor - Dec 21, 2024 · The Rise and Fall: Uncover the Players Expected to See a Drop in Their Attributes in FM24 As managers around the world prepare for the release of Football Manager 2024, another challenge lurks on the horizon: dealing with players whose attributes are on the wane. Well you want coaches to grow certain attributes and I have some weighted attributes that can point us in the right direction. I signed a coach who is a class Defensive coach and has top scouting attributes aswell to boot. With this caveat. Joined Sep 1, 2012 Messages 160 Reaction score 0 Points We also provide a handy chart showing the attribute weights for all positions and a tool for calculating your squad's current ability. Joining our Premium Membership program is the best way to make sure you have the best Football Manager experience with all the best custom-made add-ons every year. Otherwise the game will recalculate the CA according to weighted attributes, which causes a decline across the board most time. - Model Citizen Aug 18, 2015 · The CA represents a weighted "sum" of all the player's attributes - not all attributes count the same, for instance the physical ones "cost" more CA points than the mental ones. Nov 14, 2021 · Hi @Mark Janssen. You can use the figures below as a rough benchmark: 130 - Decent Premier League player; 140 - Good Premier League player May 13, 2021 · Home Page Forum General Discussion About Football Manager Game. Perfect for when you want to adjust the importance of certain attributes when it comes to the role scores calculation. cadoni. Winning a league with only a few player attributes is spectacular, but it is not the optimal. " Also, the pre-game editor will show you the weighting per attribute for the CA calculation. Attributes are weighted (e. By Ghost77, January You should probably also take a look at the staff attribute weighting May 12, 2022 · Hello, I must say that this filter gives way better ratings than the default ratings which comes with Genie Scout. Likes: 0. i think the tests show that having 1/20 passing say is less important than having 10/20 pace. Quote; Report; Share; Link to comment Share on other sites. It's the same for FM23: https: Jul 14, 2022 · Yes and no, FM Scout have a pretty good guide to how stats work (including CA and PA) here. Another thing to consider is his/her reputation within the world (World Reputation). 4 and so on). When your CA is high, close to the maximum PA, let's say your player is 140CA, but he has 160 PA At this point, his attributes will be much smaller. Jan 27, 2024 · Home Page Forum Guides, Researches and Hints for Football Manager . You can easily check this out in the pre-game editor. Meta Attributes Weighted Training Advice(Coaching Priorities) by Han106, Feb 8, 2024 . Just put defensive players outside of CBs into attacking unit and do those attacking/technical session at their intended positions. I was wondering if there was a guide or any advice/hints on what attribute level (e. Skip to content Guide to FM. The issue with these ratings is that some roles are much easier to get a high score in (for example BWM), and it doesn't mean that it is Jan 12, 2014 · Football Manager General Discussion Forums ; Football Manager General Discussion ; Current ability cost of of the attribute weighting system has evolved and changed in ways that will make it far harder for anyone to draw up a spreadsheet again with any degree of real usability with the actual players generated in the Nov 6, 2024 · 4. However, it still doesn't answer the question of how a Key vs Preferable Attribute differs in their contributions to those weighted factors. I adjusted some weights to fit first the tactic and some of my personal tastes. Part of the joy of the game is it will take a little while to adjust meaning you'd be quite likely to go past any potential sweet spots before you even realised it For example, if you look at the table then you'll see that Acceleration and Pace attributes have a very high influence on the result in Football Manager 2023 because as you can see decreasing of these attributes caused the points to drop greatly. Winning a league against AI managers isn't difficult. Staff has weighting for attributes, like players. CAE's guide to Current Ability Rating in Football Managerhttps://www. e. fmdatalab. If it's about Football Manager, Determination-Level of Discipline-Motivating is a thing of past. Meta Attribute Weighted Training Sessions: Part 2(General Best) by Han106, Jan 27, 2024 . Pace and acceleration are useful all over the pitch so I would assume they are weighted no matter the position. Jun 24, 2024 · He tried to rebuild the game's calculation. So use use all relevant attributes weighted. However, if an attribute is weighted with one or more other attributes, all associated attributes must be found. If it's about Football Manager, Attributes Weighting for each position. In the backroom meeting, he suggested I send him to scout player X. They’re really important for how well a player Nov 18, 2024 · Flashedmind said: Having analysed this post and related posts and discussions on training schedules, I think I agree with one of ZaZ's comments that you can use the physical attribute maximisation schedule in the youth team and then use the D6 schedule for the first team. ykykyk, but you could easily modify it to use ykykyk. Here are 10 reasons to join! 2 days ago · For Football Manager™ 2024, Playing Time replaces Squad Status to provide a clearer and more descriptive understanding of how a player fits into a squad. By crpcarrot, July 1 Each attribute have different weighting for each position. Feb 23, 2022 · On FM Scout you can chat about Football Manager in real time since 2011. www. Right now the Formula to calculate the rating takes the average of the role relevant attributes 4 days ago · Discover the top 5 Football Manager attributes for every position and build a dominant squad. Current 24. Go. Jan 5, 2021 · Players in Football Manager have current abilities (CA) in the range of 1 to 200. Other attributes such as Professionalism and Sportsmanship are treated as Sep 5, 2023 · Football Manager 2024 promises to provide players with the most accurate and up-to-date player attributes. comLearn how Role Scores are calculated in FMDataLab using attribute weights. However, each of those other attributes have some small influence, and when Feb 5, 2024 · Using EBFM's video and data on Additional focuses to see if any additional focus are worth trying. " So, as a manager you may wonder what exactly needs to be done in order to make the player perform to a high level. I do have a slightly different approach to weighting, though: Required attributes are weighted double to preferred attributes, similar to yourself, but un-highlighted attributes count -0. Perhaps you will find something of interest that you can use in your method. FM22 Discussion. rjp666 Member. In this guide, we'll show you how current ability (CA) is calculated based on a player's attributes and position. Technical Jul 1, 2022 · Football Manager General Discussion ; FM21 Attributes Decisions v positioning FM21 Attributes Decisions v positioning. In Football Manager, the difference between glory and defeat often boils down to the details. GF is the generic 'goes forward' SWT is stand with taker Lurk is Lurk outside the area AfD - attack from deep SB - Stay back One thing for the attacking corner roles which mostly all have the same attributes that I use "GF" (go forward) for. It was especially helpful to see which positions have weighted Attributes towards them. This data is from 1 season in his testing so perhaps multiple seasons of high growth will supplement your player's Sep 5, 2022 · Football Manager 2022. It's not hidden that match engine favor high press and fast play. Attacking. You learn a position and the specific attribute weighting changes for certain attributes. Mar 1, 2021 @ 2:32pm Originally posted by fc. Oct 17, 2009 · In FM 2009 there was issues raised surrounding the weighting and distribution of different attributes and how it was also affected by the positions the players played in, as well as CA. Once you've imported it, it should look like this: Click on one Oct 30, 2023 · I'm very new to Football Manager, previously playing FIFA for years I have finally grown up and now playing a proper game! I have a save with my local team Bristol City and we are currently in the Premier League fighting for European football after 9 seasons. Feb 6, 2024 · ZaZ said: It was just an example. By the way, I am testing the schedule below right now. Link to post Share on other sites. I don't know the exact ratios but Guide to general training on Football Manager. By Sealionborn, June 23, 2022 in Aug 20, 2023 · Thanks for your comment @enigmatic. More sharing options Join the conversation. Every attribute has a different weighting for every position. When clicking between your ratings file and the old one 'Football Manager 2016', the ratings dont seem to change, so I'm wondering if it has automatically updated to yours It keeps the Dec 5, 2021 · saycarramrod said: Looking at and testing through both ratings files from @Mark and @ZaZ I'd say if you are looking for most "bang for your buck" and maybe not a lot of money I'd use the one from Zaz as it strictly looks at the attributes table and if you have no money you can squeeze in pretty much any MFer that has important atts and they will do well. com V. 2 or 16. In some cases, that will cause players to peak with much lower attributes. I have used it to some success in a couple of saves and I want to analyse what a Poacher is doing and how you can use the role to full effect. Jan 26, 2024 · Things have changed since the last time, like a new leader , Katana 4231 104p v3. Keep in mind that it requires training with half intensity, else it will lead to a high number of injuries. Back in FM23, there was a way to "cheese" extra "Match Practice" training sessions into your schedule by saving a custom training schedule using the "Match" session. Football Manager 2021. 95 is the balance number for this position. More sharing options richard. Machismo. To me though that is very close to impossible to achieve given the number of attributes, positions, how natural a player is & how all the attributes interact with one another within the ME so its to be expected Oct 22, 2009 · I would like to understand why (at least until FM09) some attributes are "controlled" by the player's CA and some are not Looking at the attributes we can see: Aggression - I can see it not being weighted into CA, as it can sometimes be good, as it allows players to win more balls, but it can also be bad, by making it more likely to foul other players and possibly be ejected. What I decided to focus on was attributes with low CA cost, using the attribute cost table, but big Dec 31, 2021 · ZaZ said: I'll post below the study of ykykyk05251, from a basketball manager development team, about the most important attributes for each position in Blue 3. For the attribute values 5-10% subtract 2 from the attribute Aug 16, 2020 · You can use this to see what other roles a Player might be good at or just to see how good a player is overall (based on his attributes). The more important an attribute is, the heavier its weighting. Sports Interactive, the Sports Interactive logo, in-game generated images and any other Football Manager related items are registered trademarks and/or copyright material owned by Sports Interactive, or their respective Jan 25, 2021 · ZaZ said: The only way to stop a player like that is with a defender with high dirtness. Share this post#1 . That means it only starts counting after some minimum. . If you pick the attributes isolated, then you are probably right. Because if you have the better players, that is better than any in Football Manager. If you change a players positions you change the weighting of his attributes - it's not so much a cheat as it can be either a positive or negative. If there's no actual match on that day, it gets replaced by a Match Practice slot (to clarify, you place the maximum of 2 Match Feb 15, 2013 · Football Manager General Discussion ; Attribute Weighting Info Please Attribute Weighting Info Please. We also provide a handy chart showing the attribute weights for all positions and a tool for calculating your squad's current ability. Feb 8, 2024 · Home Page Forum Guides, Researches and Hints for Football Manager . Page 3 of 3. 0 CBP87. The Mar 11, 2024 · Home Page Forum Guides, Researches and Hints for Football Manager . While technical ability and Sep 5, 2024 · Attributes vs Player Ability. 85 etc. and decreases the extent to which they work on attributes. These scores are on a much finer resolution than the in-game stars, allowing you to make more Fields M to BE are the weighted attribute scores for each role in the game. elynem. sigames. Repeated, massive comprehensive training doesn't work I tried a variety of combinations (some are not in the table) Nov 5, 2023 · So the compromise I’m offering is not weighting every attribute, I want to add my view here, I have been using python scripts for more than 8 months to play football manager and I have my code base than what @olimorris or Squirrel's has created. Likes: 20. How to use it over the course of the season. With the FMDataLab Attribute Weighting functionality, you can update the weights of attributes for each of the 117 roles used in the role scores calculation. HOME Jul 14, 2021 · Home Page Forum General Discussion About Football Manager Game. lets take DC position with Chinese version and zaz -25 for under 50 modifications. By mantorras77, January 27, 2012 in I am assuming, that i. So 9. Nov 7, 2024 · At this point, his acquired attributes will be much larger. Open the excel file and make sure that you are in the correct sheet (ROLES or TRAINING or RATINGS - depends of what you exported - staff or players) and then click on "A1" cell. Nov 29, 2021 · Mark said: I decided to try and find a way to get best value for money for buying players. So if you have a striker with 17 for Finishing and still some room for development, it could be better spent increasing his poor heading ability rather than trying to get him to have 20 for Dec 24, 2023 · Open the file from Documents\Sports Interactive\Football Manager 2024 in a browser of your choice and then select all rows by pressing CTRL + A again. Posts: 20. 7 There is an upper limit to the proportion assigned to physical body classes. 5. Oddly enough, I don't even want to knowI think I like the mystery around Football Manager and it certainly keeps me coming back each year. maybe just how the weighting system for how attributes work isn't consistent across all attributes Once you've imported your squad once, you can just keep overwriting the output from step 2 and refresh the data in Excel. Personality & Media Handling matters for hidden attributes such as Professionalism, Dec 21, 2024 · Football Manager Guide - Current And Potential Ability, all you ever needed to know about current and potential ability in Football Manager. Mastering the attributes that define each player's role can give you the competitive edge needed to turn close matches into victories. Joined Sign Up To FMDataLab https://www. Their likely attribute upgrades will no doubt enhance the overall gaming experience for Football Manager enthusiasts globally. Oct 9, 2011 · Right where to start. Standard ratings on GS of my Central Defenders at St Albans My ratings of the same Central Defenders Not much between them in the standard one but wouldnt you definitely buy the top one in my ratings. Simulation attribute testing. The player ability ranges from 1 to 200, or translated in star ratings from half a star to 5 stars. 2. As I'm striving to be the best team in the world, I want the best players! Nov 9, 2009 · CAUTION: You might want to think carefully before you take a look at this: some would probably say it's cheating (because it means you end up looking at 30 or so attributes, some of them with tiny weights), and it's wholly unrealistic that a real manager would do this: it's up to us to decide on a smaller set of attributes which we think are important (as The Sean 1 day ago · The following details describe how the ratings model for non-players works in Football Manager™ 2024. Jul 18, 2012 · Football Manager General Discussion Forums ; Football Manager General Discussion ; Do players attributes mould to role? So if a player has natural (20) familiarity for centreback and 10 familiarity for DM, the weighting for each attribute will be determined 66% by CB and 33% by DM. dodge. 2 days ago · Using our exclusive Current Ability Calculator tool, you can quickly check the Recommended CA of your entire Football Manager team, as well as well calculate RCA for a single player by entering his attributes manually. For me, if I have a wingback with blistering pace and good stamina I'm pretty happy and would be okay with lower than Feb 9, 2024 · Welcome to FootballManagerGames, the most active Football Manager Community/Forum on the internet. I was using Genie Scout too before some years but the developer of the app don’t update it anymore with new features, only fixing some bugs and make it work for each Feb 1, 2021 · ZaZ said: For example, some players have 0 CA even with lots of fives and sixes. So your training strategy, when the difference between CA and the maximum PA is large, will work faster Nov 25, 2024 · Home Page Forum Guides, Researches and Hints for Football Manager . An attribute with a value of 6 or less has a weight of 0, therefore a player with 6 in all attributes will have CA 0 ZaZ said: @Grimlock SI never gives any "official numbers" on that subject but you can get a clue about the numbers by 3 days ago · The official Football Manager site can be found at footballmanager. All attributes work on the 1-20 scale, where 20 is the very best while 1 is the lowest possible value, in the same way as Player Attributes do. FM21 Discussion. fmf" inside. I came up with the best training sessions based on these weights. By the table, pace, acceleration, jumping reach, and dribbling, are by far the most important. Sep 5, 2024 · Attributes vs Player Ability. DL/DR doesn't. Base value is league average rounded up to the next number ie 10. cheeseman. Posts: 17. To make it 100 in need to devide by 9. This FM guide details what attributes are and how they impact your players. Jan 5, 2021 · The Definitive Guide to Current Ability in Football Manager. 2 . The weighting given to each attribute is the same as in the basic training schedules. fmscout. Link to the post: Did some analysis on ykykyk weights vs. Nov 2, 2023 · On FM Scout you can chat about Football Manager in real time since 2011. In relation to a player, what is the best position? Wherever he fits in your tactic. richard. AlexH. FM21 Editing Discussion. 4 Latest version, Full Attribute Test (52000 Match samples) by harvestgreen22, Nov 25, 2024 . As a premium member, you get access to super-fast direct downloads of all the graphics including our FM facepack, FM logopack, trophies pack, backgrounds and much, May 20, 2020 · That's interesting, thanks for responding. If it's about Football Manager, then it belongs here! Here you can see the weighting for attributes across all positions according to Pre-Game Editor data. By Internomad, April 20, 2023 in Football Manager General Discussion. Jul 6, 2023 · Welcome to FootballManagerGames, the most active Football Manager Community/Forum on the internet. Anyway, to answer your question Mar 9, 2017 · The Poacher is a peculiar role. Repeated, massive Physical training doesn't work Hard training (e. There are some weird Excel quirks to wrestle with, though, namely when you refresh the data it sometimes screws Nov 8, 2024 · ZaZ said: I think the mistake is to think the other seventeen attributes of the table are useless, and only three are important at all. I have searched so long all over the web to find explanations about CA and PA but i never found a definite answer so. Here are 10 reasons to join! Home › Articles › Advice › Football Manager Guides ↓ Using Machine Learning to Predict Current Ability. You can find it here. ZaZ Member. the FM Arena attribute testing. Posted Feb 6, 2024. Whether it may be the case you want to put more Apr 20, 2023 · Football Manager General Discussion ; Orange Arrows Orange Arrows. The car is evaluated in automotive design and performance through a series of static and dynamic events which focus on safety, manufacturability and of course out right speed. A winger doesnt really need heading, but a CB does, so it is weighted differently based on position. Han106. I ask you if you know how to calculate exactly Current Ability and Potential Ability without other doubt or alternatively those of SEGA who i must contact for enlightment. In FM22 the weighting is visible to people. For the attribute values 10-15% subtract 1 from the attribute table. The current ability describes the current level of football the player is at and the star rating is set according to the other players at your squad in the opinion of the Nov 13, 2023 · Home Page Forum Guides, Researches and Hints for Football Manager . by AlexH, Nov 13, 2023 . Because Genie Scout only allows whole numbers in its Jan 4, 2020 · I've isolated the stats based on the roles for quite a few positions (not all), but I'm unsure of how to weight them. An algorithm will then suggest which individual training focus to use to address weaknesses in the attributes Nov 29, 2021 · Home Page Forum Guides, Researches and Hints for Football Manager . Still the same for FM23, only exception is GK position which has some difference which is not shown in this table. Actually, Dirtiness is a negative attribute. Jun 5, 2023 · Player attributes guide how well a player performs his core skills. The video title is "Relationship between Attributes and CA in Football Manager. It's also why I Nov 22, 2018 · Hello everyone, Apologies for creating a new thread but I couldn't find any answer or guides for my question on here or elsewhere on the internet. Perfect for when you want to adjust the importance of certain Feb 2, 2024 · This is the TOP 10 of non-CA Weighted Training Sessions for EACH POSITION using weights I designed for the top tactic on the FM24 Tactic Table. 2 is 11. rtf. com and the official forums can be found at community. I think the attributes are actually 1-100 based on using CheatEngine to load the RAM in FM and having a poke around. More posts you may What would a prime Matt Le Tissier attributes be in football manager? 2 days ago · In the default Football Manager view, you can’t directly see these hidden attributes. cadoni: Yes, HoYD Personality matters. If you did a custom install it will be in a folder called Ratings under the FMGS install directory. Share this post#61 . Unfortunately I do not think the weights work like that (highest weight) based on my testing, I could not get decent results trying lots of different weight combinations. Mar 27, 2016 · Edit: The above manager was added to a Bundesliga side so I added the same profile to a Regionaliga West side, the number of known players was significantly reduced but the attribute knowledge of those players was the Feb 28, 2021 · Formula SAE and Formula Student are collegiate engineering competitions with over 500 participating schools that challenge teams of students to design and build a formula style car. Posts: 1,413. To note, AMC seems to really benefit from additional focuses. Joined Dec 14, 2020 Messages 162 Reaction score 79 Points 28. com/a-guide-to-current-ability-in-football-manager. Here is an example. Oct 18, 2023 · Removing some of the weighting, or make other stats similarly weighted is something to consider, Maybe have the stat weighting a little less linearly weighted and have positions weight the stats differently similarly to how they do already with the highlighted ones but further still with attributes of wider value. Regarding your opening post just to be clear has the attributes you edited dropped or is it just the CA ? as I take it they havent it is just the CA if this is the case report as a bug- copy and paste your initial post just cover the fact that the attributes are unchanged from using the RCA. What matters is that the match engine only uses attributes for its calculations. Jul 15, 2023 · You gotta increase the attributes to match the RCA, not increase the RCA by itself. I find it much easier to fit the player to a tactic than the tactic to the player. 2 days ago · Join our Premium Program. However, you can reveal them through the use of external tools like the FM Real Time Editor or FM Genie Scout, or by using in-game editor if they are enabled. PREV 1 2 3. It takes the players attributes, calculates their best role, which position that role is for, and then weights each attribute against the Weights tab. Coaching Attributes. I think there were about 4 or 5 attributes that were not affected whatsoever by CA, or position, about another 4 or 5 that were moderately affected and the rest heavily. As a clearer Aug 17, 2021 · I do have a slightly different approach to weighting, though: Required attributes are weighted double to preferred attributes, similar to yourself, but un-highlighted attributes count -0. Nov 14, 2023 · dzek said: Hello guys and well done for your work! @Mark & @Snaipz Why you don't use FMRTE? I think its more advanced scouting tool and also with much more flexibility on ratings etc. I also discovered a glitch on training that allows you to "super rest" players (almost 40% more recovery of condition and fatigue than just full rest schedule), but I am still investigating it Dec 14, 2020 · Football Manager 2022. Login I will also be offer an optional additional download which adds new youth talent and makes tweaks to existing player's attributes. Jan 5, 2021 · In this guide, we'll show you how current ability (CA) is calculated based on a player's attributes and position. Link to the post: Thanks for your response! 0 Jan 16, 2023 · Football Manager General Discussion ; Head of Youth Development attributes Head of Youth Development attributes. Attributes play such a big part of the game. 3 attributes, CA increased by 3. FM22 Positional Filters – what are the best attributes for each position? by Mark, Nov 29, 2021 want to make sure that the excel file can help me pick up the player who probably should perform better based on the weighted attribute table I'm using. Mar 30, 2021 · Then calculate the search values using the table above. Put it in your Football Manager 2021 -> squad views folder. May 22, 2021 · 3. Posts: 6. Some attributes have a higher ‘weighting’ towards a player’s overall ability as they are fundamentally important to succeeding in any position. For these five talents, the future is promising, both in the real world and the virtual universe of FM24. Share - a player has gained proficiency in a new position which causes the attribute weighting to be more expensive. I have used the ykykyky ratings file which finds the best players by position, I know just using acceleration and pace will result in pretty good players especially in lower divisions. Everyone has probably used it at some point in their FM career but apart from the good old “Little N Large” combo, there isn’t much most FM players can tell you about that role. The CA is essentially the weighted sum of their attributes. it shows how much CA points different attributes cost for different positions but it was tested and found that some attributes cost a lot of CA but makes no difference at Aug 8, 2018 · Take is 'taker' for corners, with my own guess as to the weights of attributes. General consensus on most important attributes for each position? by Middleweight165, Jul 14, 2021 . Edited March 19, 2022 by fc. Any player in Football Manager has both attributes and a current player ability level. Could be wrong though. Aug 6, 2022 · Having a quick look through mine, consistency and professionalism have zero weighting, but i can increase this. - player is aging, or injured long term. marking is more important for a defender than finishing) and it's therefore not completely random. ykykyk vs. Likes: 71. 4 and Jesus 18. By css_matt, February I would also assume that important attributes are heavily weighted. May 8, 2024 · Welcome to FootballManagerGames, the most active Football Manager Community/Forum on the internet. As you’ll discover, it’s not only the players who have their specific qualities and strengths. 95. At CA / PA 200, you'll still regress if you are averaging more than 16 attribute points per stat; Apr 29, 2011 · Hello everyone. On FM Scout you can chat about Football Manager in real time since 2011. A player’s current ability is distributed to the factors of current ability, which are: (Weighted) playing attributes– current ability is distributed to the player’s playing attributes on a weighted basis, with the weighting of an attribute depending on its supposed importance for the player’s playing position or positions. Mar 22, 2022 · Welcome to FootballManagerGames, the most active Football Manager Community/Forum on the internet. What rubs off is completely independent of the Influence attribute. The current ability Dec 5, 2022 · Have in mind that staff have CA/PA like players and weighting for each attribute - for each staff (like player position attributes weighting). The higher the better. Go into the game, to squad tab and import the view. Likes: 475. You're referring to the regen freak Striker in 2030 with amazing attributes and somehow 16 tackling - that's likely taking up far less than even a couple of points finishing would, right? There was a great thread on this a few years back that looked to calculate all the attribute weighting spread - is this stuff open knowledge now or Nov 12, 2016 · Football Manager General Discussion ; Please Explain This To Me (Stars vs Attributes) Please Explain This To Me (Stars vs Attributes) By Weston, November 12, 2016 in Football Manager General Discussion. All attributes where the attribute value on the table is above 15% use the base value. Mar 20, 2009 · Hello everybody. The higher Dirtiness, the higher chances of seeing the player doing some bizarre stuff like punching Jul 15, 2021 · It weights the attributes in relation to the position, with the higher weighting being the most important attribute. Thank you for your posts. Whilst the CB won't need crossing. Here are 10 reasons to join! "Understanding Player Attributes, we now know exactly what each attribute represents. There should be file "Attributes. Attribute weights for Staff; seems Negotiating is important attribute. Welcome to a brand new Football Manager guide. This reflects their competency and interest in coaching attacking Jun 23, 2022 · Currently the editor allows us to see the weighting of attributes for positions as well as a player's score for every relevant role. 0 or 16. htmlDropbox link for Excel fi Feb 15, 2013 · Football Manager General Discussion ; Attribute Weighting Info Please Attribute Weighting Info Please. van Basten Member. Values Formula. There's a graph on one of the pages that explains the Recommended CA versus the Attribute stats, and you'll find that stat saturation takes place if/when you hit 16 in all stats. Likes: 4. The higher the attributes, the better the player and higher the CA. 1. Posted Mar 11, 2024. If this is correct, Nov 11, 2023 · It uses FMScout attribute weights for positions vs. The resulting player rating Dec 5, 2020 · Football Manager 2021. 2 (with the except of some non-role So, on the "Weights" tab the attributes are weighted for every position and you wrote that these weights are from the editor, so I suppose they are correct. Dec 30, 2009 · physical attributes for example have a massive weighting on them compared to technical ones, hence why theo walcott has apparently poor attributes, yet if you look he is just exceptionally fast. Posted March 19, 2022. Home; Tactics. Feb 5, 2024 · Regardless, my focus is towards the growth of attributes towards weights that I created for the top tactic. Posts: 83. yeah, wouldn't do that. All of them have weighting on the player's ability. From weighting of attributes for each position, you can see that physical attributes is the most important - must have for each position. using all attribute weights above 35 in a formula for each position and applying it for each position. And of course the well known both-footedness problem. We also provide a handy chart showing the attribute Attribute Weights. 1, I also am using more weights based on the @ZaZ's under 50 minus 25 weights from the linked post. Page 1 of 3. Aug 17, 2021 · I have something similar running via Google Sheets (with some back-end scripting to run through an entire squad and analyse each player's best role). as said earlier in thread if you want to have a workaround - Jan 13, 2023 · This is the weighting of attributes for each position according to Pre-Game Editor. Link to the post: Jan 5, 2021 · The Definitive Guide to Current Ability in Football Manager. (I also use a different modified version for my saves that stresses other attributes and gives different weights to attributes Apr 13, 2024 · View the full Attribute Weights tutorial here. So I sent him to scou Nov 29, 2024 · harvestgreen22 said: I tested them on Q8-T8 Thanks again for your hard work! Seems that the extra Match Practice slots are mostly good at maximizing CA growth while minimizing the number of training slots used. Aug 20, 2023 · On FM Scout you can chat about Football Manager in real time since 2011. Posted Jul 15, 2021. The reason is, I see way more players which perform in-game better than the rest with your filters. Jan 1, 2009 · CA is a total of points that are distributed for attributes. You can specify any attribute you like, but when you start a game, any attributes with the value 0 (random) will be randomized, but taking the CA into consideration. I don't want to give attributes away about players and staff so bare with my explanation. I think (not very sure) that the formula of Determination - Ambition - Professionalism factors of development for players, apply for Dec 23, 2023 · It is good that we have found Meta-Attributes but we should see these attributes in the right context and not in a "I don't care all other attributes" attitude because this is not adequate. Jul 7, 2022 · Five attributes meaning I am rating players out of 100, therefore giving attributes equal weightingsimply because I don't know the exactness of what makes the most difference in the match engine**. MENU MENU FM Blog - Football Manager 2024 Community SEARCH. Here are 10 reasons to join! For most attributes if you use a general weighting of 100 and a attribute weighting of 100 (or -100 for the 'negative' attributes). I've bolded on the top ones that are high percent growth and high scoring. So the reason why I Nov 29, 2021 · - Decisions is generally weighted almost half of what the CA Attribute Weights say, even though all positions in the tactic have Take More Risks enabled. Then I take players attributes and multiply them with the approriate weights for each position. Great thanks to ahstzl1989 for translating the entire text 6 days ago · Why Physical Attributes Matter in Football Manager In Football Manager, physical attributes can be the difference between a world-class player and one who never quite reaches their potential. Jul 26, 2010 · Football Manager General Discussion Forums ; Football Manager General Discussion ; How do attribute points add up to create each player? Attributes carry weighting as I've explained up the page. 1 2 NEXT. In today's article, we delve into the lives of five footballers facing potential declines in FM24. #2. I forget who did the research, Feb 1, 2023 · The Football Manager attribute analysis spreadsheet is updated for Football Manager 2023 and gives you an percentage value of a players most suited player role and duty. Jan 26, 2023 · Football Manager General Discussion Forums ; Football Manager I've been paying close attention to staff decision making for awhile now and comparing it to the staff attribute weighting chart created by fc. com. cadoni to try to understand why they make certain suggestions and what other factors besides SI's highlighted stats Nov 27, 2022 · Zippo said: For example, 'Decisions' attribute is very expensive for every position and it costs almost the same as 'Acceleration' or 'Pace' attributes but 'Decisions' attribute almost doesn't have any significant impact on the result unlike the 'Acceleration' or 'Pace' attributes, which have a great impact on the result. Take this screenshot below as an example. G group) Pace, Acceleration, Jumping reach increased by 3. Oct 17, 2022 · Football Manager Guide to Staff Attributes and Non-Playing Tendencies. We also provide a handy chart showing the attribute weights for all positions and a tool for calculating your May 13, 2023 · As you probably already know, attributes in FM only display on a scale from 1 to 20, but in fact they are from 1-100 (because player can have for example Accelaration: 16. In other words, low Decisions is a good step to get a Sep 7, 2011 · As has been stated above, Influence is merely how much the Captain's personality "rubs off" on other players. Mar 19, 2022 · Football Manager General Discussion Forums ; Football Manager General Discussion ; Staff has CA/PA as well with attributes having different weighting for each member. Without the use of the extra MPs, every schedule that has a CA growth of 24 or better uses 6 or more training slots. Here are 10 reasons to join! Home › Articles › Advice › Football Manager Guides ↓ Player Attributes Explained Attributes are rated from 1 to 20 – with 20 being the highest rating to Nov 29, 2021 · Mark said: Make sure you downloaded the right Ratings file - link is at post #103 in this thread. So you can come back later (even on a different device) to view the player-calculated scores without needing to re-upload each time! 🥳 Using the provided views by FMDataLab, you can export from these views in As you've pointed out though, that approach isn't perfect. Football Manager 2022 Guide. FB might have higher attribute weighting in speed, crossing, etc than if the player were only a CB. Nov 7, 2023 · You can look at this older guide made by @PriZe (it has a section about roles & attributes, much hasn't changed I think. May 26, 2023 · That site has some great information and I appreciated the link. Jul 23, 2022 · If a player already has a decent value for a highly-weighted attribute, further development in that attribute is essentially at the expense of potential growth in other attributes. Jan 27, 2012 · Football Manager General Discussion ; CA vs Attributes vs Star Ratings CA vs Attributes vs Star Ratings. You also probably Feb 26, 2022 · The calculator shows the average weighted attribute for each role and duty (/20) as well as showing this as a percentage. Offline. It's the same for 22, 23, 24 versions. For FST is 7. A natural attribute to "cut" for better CA spread. For example, for DC player I am looking: - Acceleration- Pace- Jumping Reach- Strength- Positioning- Decisions- Anticipation- Tackling- Marking- Heading May 25, 2022 · Physical attributes are weighted by the match engine a little to a lot more heavily than mental or technical attributes. So basically your examples are void as a player with current ability of 0 would have every attribute of 0 (not possible anyway) and a player with current ability 200 would Nov 27, 2024 · Hi, @harvestgreen22, thank you so much for the research you put into this. g. Member. Share this post#14 . Download FMDataLab Views from Here: h May 10, 2022 · View community ranking In the Top 1% of largest communities on Reddit Key vs. Dec 31, 2021 #1 The values in the above table can also be used as attribute weights to calculate the weighted average value of the attributes and then calculate the "Tactical True CA" Jan 27, 2024 · It uses the attribute weights from the pre-game editor along with all the key/preferred attributes for the different roles. Link to ykykyky balanced Ratings file The standard place for Genie Scout ratings files is C:\FM Genie Scout 22g\Ratings. Sep 21, 2021 · Parse Attributes Parse Players from . R. I believe this proves that decisions isn't nearly as important as the game wants us to believe, even when the players are given creative freedom. The total sum of the weights is 995. The assistant manager thinks that Saka is best as a right winger and Jesus a striker, which means that certain attributes are going to be worth more to a winger than a striker, like crossing (Saka 14, Jesus 12), which when weighted turn into Saka 26. How do I read this weighting table? by Machismo, May 13, 2021 . Football Manager 2024 Mobile ; Our Football Manager Careers section lets fans track and share their Football Manager Stories. Dec 14, 2023 · Tavares82 said: I have some questions about the fm genie scout. The Physical Trainings only weighted the Physical Jan 4, 2020 · Football Manager General Discussion Forums ; Football Manager General Discussion ; Weight of attributes per role (and general spreadsheet geeking) @XaW I've tried weighting those secondary attributes at 80% of the primary but like you I can't settle on an exact number. By css_matt, February 15, 2013 in Football Manager General Discussion. Upload Your Football Manager Exports Signing up to FMDataLab allows you as a user to upload your exported Football Manager Files, those files will link to your user. This time I’ll explain the staff attributes and non-playing tendencies in Football Manager. 8. 2 (with the except of some non-role Mar 20, 2010 · A few versions ago, a lot of research was done on the weighting of various attributes by position to find out how best to optimise training. Additionally, scouts and coaches with high Judging Player Ability or Judging Player Potential can provide reports that hint at Aug 24, 2009 · Far too late for FM2010 I would have thought unless they include it in one of the patches. Nov 29, 2021 · Each attribute weight for each position was then turned into a percentage of the total attribute scores for that position. Share this post#30 Nov 11, 2024 · ZaZ said: Just be mindful when training players in different positions, as that will increase their attribute weighting for defining CA. #9 < > Showing 1-9 of 9 comments Jun 12, 2022 · Attribute Updates + New Player Requests FM22 FM24/25 Update Discussion posted on sortitoutsi Data Update Discussion for Football Manager 2024/25. kcpwegltbxkbtxltuiltyyomwjmrazugwyhazsohevkz