Minthara and karlach same party. kill 3 leaders and speak to the druid .
- Minthara and karlach same party I keep every character at the same AC so the AI spreads its attacks out without focusing anyone in particular. I go to Minthara I repeat the same conversation described above hoping that now that there are no cutscenes something will Karlach - Bear Rage Barbarian Ye not exactly inventive but it absolutely crushes everything on sight on tactician. I want to do a dark urge playthrough with minthara and karlach in the same party, I have a soft spot to karlach she is just to wholesome, I don't want to kill her Minthara: In Menzoberranzan, after a house has two sons, every subsequent male-born child is slaughtered at birth, as it is useless, even for breeding. Can Minthara and Shadowheart be on the same party? As the post title suggests, this is my first time playing the game and I wanna keep Shadowheart for progressing in her quest/relationship, I was wondering if siding with Minthara when it comes to the grove would make it impossible to do that or make her leave the party. In her romance wrap-up scene, Minthara demands to go to Avernus together and make Zariel sorry for ever hurting her, and accepting proceeds to Same. I received the same Tiefling setup as though I sided with the Grove in Act 1. I know that she and wyll leave if you atta k the grove, but if I tell Minthara the location, then switch on her there will Karlach still leave the party, or is it only if you kill the tieflings? I've killed Minthara on my first playthrough, and now I want to keep her, but at the same time I want to romance the fire mommy. Open comment sort options. How To Recruit Minthara. But besides this quest line, it is at least still possible to both have Minthara AND karlach in the same party? Same. Shame. Paintings and drawings I don't remember Lae'zel have any story moments in Act 2, but Karlach does. New comments cannot be posted. The only reason Karlach and Wyll stay is because you didn't do it yourself. Minthara's view of the entire party is pretty insightful. Is there as of right now after the Patch, ANY way to accomplish this? Some origin characters are also faster than others. Have you reported it to Larian? There are costs if you want Karlach and Wyll in your party but I went with Minthara, Shadowheart and Lae'zel. Also managed to save Dammon from the slaughter of the This results in the same setting as vanilla where they are imprisoned for judgement. Remember that recruiting Minthara involves making certain decisions that will affect the storyline. Just don’t bring Halsin when you’re trying to recruit her. ” (The party knows about it from Dhourn’s Memory Shard): “More talk of that forge. This is an optional step but lets you tag them along as well. Then attempt to stealth kill the Leaders except Mintara, avoid battle with Mintara at So Minthara had an out through him if she wanted to live her post and be a surface Drow. Help him, and kill all of the goblins in the room. Karlach is still in party, Minthara is on our side and the journal says Zevlor and the Tieflings have moved on. Archived post. The grove will end up falling but karlach and will shouldnt leave your party iirc. I ignored her on my first play through, mainly because I didn't find her until the eend of act I, and on my second I wanted her, Wull, Minthara and Astrion, but upon reaching ActII I screwed something up and Minthara wasn't there so I started a new Dark Urge, killed Wyll There is an exploit where you can team up with Minthara (sort of) and still keep Karlach and Wyll with you, but you won't be able to help Karlach. I thought Halsin would give me an ultimatum, so I did Nathanial's whole thing before going to Moonrise the first time to save Minthara and the other prisoners. Then I had Astarion join my party and got his approval rate up and he wanted to smash on the same night I had Minthara in the camp so I had to choose. I also figured out blowing the horn or cutting Zevlor's neck is a no-no. [] Talk to Minthara after dumping a companion and making a slot for her. Can you have Karlach and Minthara at the same time? With no mods and I have Karlach, Minthara and Wyll. I do see shadow and lae'zel fitting in with minthara especially laezel if she felt betrayed enough by vlaakith and her peoples same with shadow however not too sure about Karlach tho. It's crazy cause there really are minthara dialogues for both karlach and wyll, so I assume she has some about halsin Reply reply And in Act 2, Minthara and Haslin are both in camp at the same time and can be placed into a party on the most recent patch with no mods? Minthara has dialogue for Karlach and Wyll even though both leave if you do choose to get Minthara, she also has dialogue pertaining to act 2 and 3 wyll and karlach events. Baldur's Gate III is based on a modified version of the Dungeons & Dragons 5th edition (D&D 5e) tabletop RPG I'm trying to get into a polyamorous relation with minthara and shadowheart and I keep getting conflicting information concerning whether that's even a possibility. Before we get started, there are a couple of things we need to go over regarding Minthara and this guide. It was made to sound like they got the "good" transition to Baldurs Gate. Do they have dialogue and/banter with each other now? Or is it more of a Halsin/Minthara situation, where there isn't much there yet? Locked post. She can enter a (literally!) fiery rage, attacking enemies with abandon and quickly chipping away at their health. CarrygunN I was Karlach and Shadowheart together are only available through an exploit (or were, it might have been patched, and I don't know the details). I’ve just met Jaheira at the harper camp too and wanted too know some do’s and do nots for getting them both as companions. Both K and W will leave you turn on you if you attack the grove. 9% certainty they are Halsin and Minthara). Act 2. However, you’d also lose: Wyll Karlach Minthara - She is very power hungry. The other request I have, is to let her and Halsin be in the party at the same time. Knocking out seems quite useless in general, might be made for Paladin oath or something. Minthara Changes in Patch 7. Minthara: You have the aura of a third child about you. One thing I can think and will test later is that I left her dead but in my party. Do not pick a side in the grove battle. The other way you can do it is just by constantly long resting in Act 1 until the grove gets closed on its own and the druid ritual is completed. My Tav romanced Astarion and they were It is in fact possible to get Minthara and Karlach if you entirely skip grove quests. Then tell Minthara you agree to help kill the grove. 8. so i imagine at one point there was a way to have them all that BG 3: How to Recruit Minthara Without Losing Karlach and Wyll. Yes you can, by skipping the Grove vs Goblin camp, finish as much quests as you According to a reddit post from yesterday, in order to have Karlach and Wyll in the same party as Minthara is you have to completely ignore the attack the grove quest. Kill druids and/or tieflings before recruiting Karlach (even if not sided officially with the goblins ok so yes in the release there is a way. So, now go step by step: You can now tell her where the I knocked out Minthara before I wiped out the goblins, so I’m hoping she’ll show up in act two as a possible part member. Gale has to be persuaded to stay. It's all about the Tieflings. Wyll and Karlach only leave if you yourself actually commit the slaughter of the grove. Do NOT meet her there or she will kill you. Have them jump into the chasm. Go to the dungeons and into the first room on the left and shut the door. Then since minthara successfully raided the grove, she can be recruited in act 2. Literally the only thing that stops you from recruiting her is killing her. The Tieflings will probably end up dead along with Dammon What happens to Karlach if you don't tune up her engine in Act 2 at Last Those who have played Baldur's Gate 3 since it was first released will likely remember that there was originally no way to recruit both Halsin and Minthara in the same playthrough. I plan on doing everything I can in the game eventually, but I find Karlach to be just a very well written character because shes fun, and its hard to write fun people, people with humor, a personality besides the same old "I have a tough exterior but heart is soft" its like yeah ok get in line with the rest of the failed authors that try to So since we can get Minthara without killing the grove, I'm doing that. To do this, I had to kill Karlach in my camp before the raid. All you do is just ignore the grove situation. Minthara can be saved and recruited to the party. I have seen many clips/gameplay parts from other people in the last weeks, and I never see that someone has Minthara in their party (most likely because of the choice you have to make). I'd been meaning to do a playthrough as one of the origin characters (most likely Karlach) but was burned out and decided to take a break. Now that Minthara is en route, go to Halsin. Mostly because outside of the "good path", the I raided the grove, but somehow kept Karlach. It's fully intended. I did the same but Karlach and Wyll leave the camp when the celebration Gather your party and venture forth! Karlach, and Minthara. Which means Minsc probably won't either. You will lose Halsin and the Tieflings though. Have Zrell show compassion for Minthara and she gets sent to the prisons. No luck for Halsin though iirc. so yes you can do a balanced party with Wyll, Karlach, Durge, and Shadowheart. NPCs that are not going past certain events that are already resolved and Wyll wants to talk but then only says the standard things. BG3 is the third main game in the Baldur's Gate series. With the aforementioned frequency Their tents also are in the same spot so im guessing they might have overlooked Minthara and Halsin both being in the party at the same time. I'm not sure about the data mine info. I wanted to have a playthrough where I leaned good, but still managed to recruit Minthara. The first thing is that this guide will have spoilers for Act 1 and the beginning of Act 2. You don't have Minthara's tadpole because you will only get it when she is actually dead. Siding with minthara automatically removes wyll and karlach from your party. Wanted to know if anyone has tried to get with them both at the same time. In the game's current version, players can keep both companions by knocking out Minthara in the goblin camp instead of killing her, and then continuing with Halsin's questline. Add a Comment [deleted] • Just note that, story-wise, it's the same as having slaughtered the tieflings. I want minthara as a companion but I can’t get her unless I raid the grove, but if I raid the grove then I lose karlach. If you’re playing Baldur’s Gate How to Recruit Minthara Without Losing Karlach and Wyll! Can you get both Minthara and halsin? Normally, you can either get Minthara or Halsin as your BG3 I'm going really slow taking my time to do everything so I did't got to Karlach yet, but I know Wyll wants to find her and possibly hunt her (basically the first thing he says to me). They definitely should let you take Minthara to the Underdark and Cresche map. The companions you can get are: Side with the Grove: Everyone except Minthara, though that can be changed with mods Side with the Goblins: You can recruit Minthara, but lose Wyll, Karlach, and Halsin. (I did not kill Razglin either but I suspect you still can with no effect) Proceed to Act 2 at your leisure. However, the content she has is really interesting and well written. With Patch 5, can you now romance Minthara and Karlach? Originally you couldn’t have both characters at the same time, and the general rule for poly romances is one origin character and one non-origin character, so I was wondering if the fact that you can have both characters now means they can both be romanced Gather your party and Gather your party and venture forth! The only (intended) method of doing it is to play as Karlach yourself and recruit Minthara normally. Astarion is consistent, and with relatively good progression. Go to the Shattered Sanctum in Goblin Camp and save Halsin. Recruiting Minthara is a long quest, and getting her causes some bad things to happen. I also want to be able to progress Karlach's quest (and afaik, Minthara doesn't have anything beyond one scene). Karlach just a muscle woman with childish personalty and wants to fuck just for i dont know, not killing her on spot. ) Finally went to recruit Karlach after all is said and done Essentially doing everything involving the grove quest before recruiting Karlach. Basically i wen't to the Gith Creche first, then goblin camp, i didn't sweep the camp instead i convinced Minthara to let me talk to Halsin, at this time the Druid camp was rooted over so Halsin had no where else to go but to my camp. Why did Wyll and Karlach leave my party . Spoilers : You go and recruit Karlach and Wyll and do all tasks related to them. In Act II, Minthara will now react to you having knocked her out in Act I. She will heal your party during that fight. Top. His dialogue is different if you already talked to Minthara. Already killed Halsin too, that scene is HILARIOUS to me 3 - When you get to moonlight tower you'll have both sazza and minthara being judged by ketheric, claim mercy for minthara and to free the goblins 4 - Go to the prison and free minthara (no need to save the halfings/gnomes yet) and fight your way out of moonlight tower (around the kitchen counter clockwise from the balcony is the safest way). Halsin and Minthara will likewise not acknowledge one another and their camps will overlap as they aren't supposed to be in the same party by default. Karlach and Wyll absolutely don't care if you don't save the tieflings (as long as you just don't kill them yourself) I've only played through the game twice, and both times as a created character (Tav and Dark Urge). Gale also leaves if you fail a skill check. Karlach is very different, a person who means well but goes about it in a blundery chaotic barbarian manner. ) Recruit Minthara and go through the party 3. We are going to try and kill Wyll and see if we revive him only after act 1 is done if he can stay with us. Then go pick up Karlach and hopefully she doesn't mention the grove because it's already done and she wasn't there for it. 3: then you Recruit Minthara by doing the raid, there will be no 'battle raid' cause However Minthara is very bugged, and even though she has lines acknowledging Wyll and Karlach they also have some lines referencing her which you can't normally hear. So I reloaded a bunch til I got lucky and got my whole party to go first in the turn order ( I was using Karlach and Astarion by Minthara and Lae'zel by Sazza and the orb on the other side of the bridge (I made sure to carry Sazza over there before throwing the orb into the pit)), got Sazza and Minthara knocked out on turn 1, then had Lae'zel As a Barbarian, Karlach’s damage potential is pretty much limitless. 2/3 of the goblin bosses killed, obviously left Minthara. For the Community Wiki, lore, and other details, check out the pinned Weekly Q&A Post. Gale leaves as well unless persuaded. I simply want to have Karlach and Minthara in the same party, AND being able to progress Karlachs questline. Idk if you can simply ignore Karlach and not pick her up until you raid the grove though. Both times were also 'good' playthroughs. Hi people. I don’t remeber the exact details of how to do it but their post was somewhere on this subreddit So if you do this does minthara actually have voice lines commenting on wyll or karlach situations? (companions No, shockingly I didnt make a save right before the party when I first got there weeks ago so I could prove a point on reddit. It is not the same, Karlach was pretty much a prisoner from the word go. In act 2, I Ah fuckballs, was in the process of doing the same thing and just entered the shadowlands on my way to Moonrise. Reply reply You can't have Wyll/Karlach and Minthara at the same time unless you go down a very specific, unconventional path Reply reply This is a result of Baldur's Gate 3's fifth major patch, which tightened up some of the unintended interactions around Wyll and Karlach's intertwined Act 1 quests, including the ability to have Mizora reward Wyll without permanently killing Karlach. Question about Karlach, Minthara, and Dammon upvotes Allow them to take Minthara to the prison for mind wiping. They both permanently left my camp. Here are my ideas: Tav, Minthara, Halsin, and Gale or Tav, Karlach, Halsin, and Gale. If you don't kill her, even if you don't raid the grove, you can recruit her at moonrise without Karlach or Wyll leaving the party. r/ImaginaryWesteros. I'm doing Act2 rn and idk if the romance will progress bc she does not recognised Karlach as her lover when i Minor spoilers ahead. And Larian has stated that only two companions in the game are mutually exclusive (99. Enter the interrogation room and talk to the interrogators, then attack them. Recruit Karlach (and Wyll) as normal, don't talk to Sazza, don't talk to or touch Minthara or any goblin leaders in goblin camp or tell her about grove, and to it went fine! The only odd thing was Minthara and Halsin sharing the same tent/bed (depending on the camp) but tbh that was more funny than anything else. You will keep all party members except Halsin, who dies off-screen. Start by recruiting Wyll, through him you can get Karlach’s location. Can't wait to have a party Karlach, Shadowheart, and Lae'zel and see how they all argue amongst one another. She promises the reward for killing the druids/tieflings at the Grove at the party. i feel bad but im not gonna do another evil run and getting minthara is A community all about Baldur's Gate III, the role-playing video game by Larian Studios. Go to Moonrise (after Last Light intro) and finish the recruitment quest for Minthara. Save Dammon so you can progress Karlachs quest? I do not care about ANY druid, or Halsin or Kahga or whatever. Bosses in BG3 are powerful enemies that have increased health and pose a bigger challenge for players. Recruit Minthara. The first consequence is that Halsin can't be recruited short of using convoluted methods to convince the game to allow both Halsin and Go tell Minthara the location of the grove. I killed Karlach and Wyll, but traveled extensively with Karlach to get a high approval. Wyll left me when I revived him, but Karlach stayed, but she had a massive hatred towards me. so no lol at a certain point you gotta choose between them. So story wise, is best to take Karlach with you. Minthara is written as strictly monogamous tho. Same thing sort of happened to me. I've been playing around with this a little. Karlach/Laezel (Same for Karlach and Wyll, both will leave the party if you try to raid the grove with them) To get them both you have to side with the grove and kill the goblin leaders, but use non-lethal attacks to knock out minthara rather than killing her. That was after I had my romance night with shadowheart which happened around 40 approval. The written interaction is likely to allow the player to follow the story thread of protecting the Druid Grove and keeping Minthara alive so that they can retain Wyll and Karlach in the party . It's pretty sad that if you want Karlach in your party, you are forced to kill Others have reported that there's banter between Minthara and Karlach, and that it may be possible to max out Karlach's favor before betraying the tieflings, allowing her to stay. get minthara at moonrise. Halsin - Can oversee some things, but good alignment overall. Locked post. I’ve already tried killing karlach in the camp and then proceeding with the raid but it still says she leaves my camp after the raid and when I rez her she tells me she’s leaving and then she’s gone. Stealing the idol for Mol is one of two ways people are able to recruit Minthara/Wyll/Karlach in the same run. Send her to your camp. Reply reply This is the most apparent path. From what it seems, she has successfully raided the Grove, killing only the Druids and some non-quest Tieflings, while still having Karlach in her party. Start the dialogue and opt to rescue Minthara from her torturers. BG3 Minthara can be found at Shattered Sanctum. Leave her sitting there dead in camp until I recruited Minthara in act 2 and then used Withers to resurrect Karlach. ) Stole the Idol of Silvanus, causing the grove to essentially go in to a civil war 2. Larian Is there a way to save Karlach AND have Minthara in party? I really wanna test out Minthara, but not doing a chaotic evil run (more like neutral/chaotic good), so I helped the tieflings in the This Baldur’s Gate 3 Minthara and Halsin guide will teach players how to get Minthara in the same party as Halsin, Karlach, Wyll and Gale. Recruited Karlach and left her dead. In the same dialogue, also fixed mind flayer Karlach disappearing and a mocap pop. If you haven't played before and are only going to do one run, this trade off probably won't be worth it to you and you should maybe consider recruiting Minthara by KO and not wasting the grove to keep Wyll and Karlach. Larian has stated that Minthara and Halsin are supposed to be mutually exclusive, and have patched the game to prevent one method of recruiting both. A camp night scene with Shadowheart will no longer trigger if she's not in the party and, uh, also dead. Split your party. the devs definitely did account for this, there is a line of dialogue where the dream visitor comments on my expeditious progress and asks if maybe I should have helped in the grove, but other times I think Minthara is an NPC and potential Boss or Companion in Baldur's Gate 3 (BG3). You will only miss her scene of celebration in camp with goblins. Minthara is a ruthless Drow that is preparing an assault on Druid Grove. You can have wyl/karlach and minthara by simply not resolving the grove but it seems to be buggy. The second thing is that Minthara has a lot of bugs surrounding her interactions. To start, if you actively assist in the goblin raid on the Druid Grove, Started a second playthrough of a kinda-evil Dark Urge character, been prepping my party and I decided that I wanted Karlach and Minthara on the same team. Shadowheart is the only in my current evil co-op run we just killed Karlach with Wyll. My most recent run was Light Cleric Shadowheart, Rogue/Bard Astarion, and Paladin Minthara for most of the game, with me as a Draconic Sorcerer. 2: Have Karlach and Wyll steal the idol from the groove, this causes a 'civil war' and in the process you let Karlach and Wyll die. If you’re playing Baldur’s Gate 3, you might want to recruit the Drow Paladin, Minthara, into your group. Reason why I have these 4 together. 1. Not due to her character, but because in the current lack of content, Minthara and Halsin don't acknowledge each others' existence. Mage armor works on her pretty well since she's unarmored. The memory shard already Spoke to Minthara but didnt tell her the location of the grove Started Act 2 clearing everything else and the following occoured. MC has good Karlach is not given the option to sleep with Minthara after completing Raid the Emerald Grove; however, the latter can be romanced upon recruiting her to the party and upgrading Karlach's engine. Share Sort by: Best. It's emotionally difficult for many players due to the Tiefling children and it will cause Wyll and Karlach to leave permanently. Share this post: 2nd playthrough as seldarine drow bard with probably the same party as playthrough 1 (1st playthrough to romance Astarion, 2nd for Gale lmao) Shadowheart/Minthara (and romancing one of the women, idk which one yet because just look at them!) Reply reply WellPlayed_139 I think I want Karlach in my party. Lae'zel react on Karlach Devil joining the Party Baldur's Gate 3 upvote r/ImaginaryWesteros. sons alive at the same time lmao. Currently also in Act 2 like you. Yes they are Act 1 zones but they are different map loadscreens so they could be made an exception She can join you and you can keep everyone in your party. You can do Astarion and Halsin at the same time, but not Minthara and Astarion I really liked Minthara - beyond being a vengeance paladin w solid stats, her character opens up a lot after act 2, and she is much more of a military strategist and noble type than a frenzied monster while under the absolutes influence. Halsin had usual dialogue options. but really wanted Minthara in my party with karlach to finish refugee quest that is bound with the druid quest you have few options: 1. I really want to have Minthara and Halsin in the same party. (either as the same word or a different word) in multiple Shadowheart and Astarion are the only polyamorous companions in the game and only with Halsin. There used to be an P. Im using a mod that allows me to have more than 4 in a party so i want to bring everyone, and see all the dialog with all the companions in various scenes. As far Combat, Karlach is just an Auto attacker with a lot of HP. Act 1 - Spoilers I just finished defending the grove against the goblins and when I went to full rest. Best. Without reclassing or multiclassing you probably want Shadowheart for act 2 instead of Karlach (also makes sense for story/reactivity). hi I tried origin karlach just to romance minthara and there's some interesting dialogue changes at the gobling party in act 1 but she doesn't sleep with karlach at all. I think lae’zel made a move on me before 20 approval. I want to romance Astarion this playthrough, but I don't know whether sleeping with Minthara will ruin that. Minthara escapes if the Goblins turn on her only to be recaptured at moonrise -Bring the Idol of Silvanus to Minthara as proof of their (The party knows about it from Dhourn/Dhourn’s corpse): “Ol' Dhourn was searching for that same forge. While Astarion, Laezael and Shadowheart don't give a shit about this slaughter, Gale is reluctant to stay with us and Wyll left us without hesitation. You'll just have to trust I'm not lying for no reason when I tell you I had all of Karlach's act 1 scenes, then at the party she told me to hang out with someone else, so I hung out with (and even kissed) Shadowheart, and the Karlach romance continued like Gather your party and venture forth! But I want Shadow and Karlach and Minthara. Just leave her there to ponder her attack. Right now, Karlach is pretty deeply in disapproval of my Tav, where when I talk to her in camp she just says "what," but Minthara has an exceptional approval of him. Wyll, Karlach, and Halsin leave your party permanently if you side with the goblins against the druids/tieflings, which is required to recruit Minthara. //WALL OF TEXT CRITS YOU!// Spoilers, obviously, but I just wanted to chime in here and say that attempting to get all three of these characters in the same party without going the typical "good route" was an exercise in frustration. Meet up with the goblin party after traveling through the mountain pass. I’ve just started my Minthara romance run and I’m already so deeply attached to her. Here are the answers to some common questions related to Just Started Act 2, helped the goblins, and Minthara waits for me at Moon rise, currently it’s just been me and shadow heart this trip so there hasn’t been any conflicts within the party. In the prison, kill the scrying eyes first using turn based mode, then the guards standing outside her interrogation room. 7. S: To recruit Minthara, Karlach and Wyll in the same play without bug or mods is easy: 1. yea. Assuming I’m able to recruit her, how long can I keep her and Karlach in the same party? I haven’t decided yet what my Shadowheart is going to do with Nightsong. Open comment sort options Even Karlach commented about kidnapping “her Minthara”. Minthara will be in a jail in Moon Towers as she supposed to be. Minthara and Karlach [edit | edit source] (At Abandoned Cistern in the Lower City Sewers) Minthara: This place is foul. I wouldn't risk anything like that, as it might get patched at any point, and it might mess up your endings anyway. You can find it under the 'Hot' filter on desktop or 'Hot Posts' on Mobile. Still functions just fine in fights. Ensure Minthara is imprisoned and not executed. I met Minthara in the goblin camp, but did not give her the location to the druid camp. The only real switch is Karlach and Minthara, but I intend to keep that slot for a melee focused character to balance my Tav and Gale as spellcasters. I know it's not possible to do both at the same time, even if you manage to keep them in party together I have two potential parties depending on if I recruit Minthara or not. Add a Comment. Only Karlach and Yes, it is possible to have both Minthara and Karlach in your party at the same time in Baldur’s Gate 3. then you go to the goblin camp and kill all gobbos and leaders BUT you do not touch Minthara. you recruit Karlach and Wyll. But thanks to Withers only the race and specific unique buffs are fixed. This ties back to Minthara, because despite the fact that there's a way to have both Minthara and Karlach in your party, Minthara even has dialogue about her admiration for Karlach, if Minthara is in your party, Dammon is dead. My only theory currently is: getting Karlach first upgrade ASAP with minimal talking to druids or teiflings > sparing Minthara in Act 1 but not killing the teiflings > going through the underdark to Act 2 > going straight to Last Light to speak to Dammon > going back through the underdark immediately > going back to Act 2 via the mountain pass Gather your party and venture forth! I play stupid Emperor cutscene. Same for Will. You do not need to choose between them or sacrifice one for the other. Reply Karlach is a goody goody who doesn't approve of anything you do unless it is getting in her pants. The conditions to keep them in the party past act 1 are mutually exclusive. Additionally, while any player who made use of the loophole pre-patch would get to keep the Infernal Robe, Wyll's This Baldur’s Gate 3 Minthara and Halsin guide will teach players how to get Minthara in the same party as Halsin, Karlach, Wyll and Gale. You in fact can see in Fextralife's most recent video that he has Karlach and Wyll in his party. Minthara is recruitable without losing Karlach and Wyll in a vanilla playthrough. Help Minthara find the Grove and kill all the Druids and the Tieflings. The only other ways to do it involve exploiting bugs to do so, which may cause other things to bug out. In Baldur’s Gate 3 Minthara is an evil character and taking her normally requires you to This mined information shows that Larian Studios did consider the possibility of Halsin and Minthara being in the same party, if only briefly. She seems a bit more on the good side. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. She will test you. kill 3 leaders and speak to the druid ok i gonna tell you i went for minthara, and it was a disappointment she has 0 content in Act 3, she doesn't even said anything when you met up with orin. Halsin did not comment on Minthara at all, and Minthara had very little to say about Halsin. Somone on her got halsin and minthara in the same party by knocking her into the abyss and then recruiting her in act 2 i belive. If wyll leaves so be it, but it would be funny to have him and minthara in the same party. Could you potentially get both Minthara and Karlach on the same team? If Minthara never finds the grove, no raid takes place and you can recruit her in Act 2, without losing Wyll and Karlach. She also opens more options for you in Act 3, taking her with you will be more fun. Minthara was willing to work within the extremely fucked society that is Menzoberranzan because her family was in charge. Laezel have two absolutely sudden changes(one with acceptance of "heresy", other one in 3rd act make some kind of softie, and its weird. take the underdark to get into act 2 3. Check out our FAQ for information regarding creating builds and other general questions. Now though I have other problems coming up that might be linked. I did a morally grey campaign where I helped the tieflings, killed everything in sight on the goblin camp except Minthara and then went to act2, sure thing I lost most of the tieflings but still managed to follow a good path, recruit Minthara without losing Is Minthara worth losing Halsin? Yes, I think so, even as a Halsin Liker. Minthara is a powerful and evil optional party member that can only be acquired if you choose to work with the Cult of the Absolute and destroy the Emerald Grove in Act 1 Gather your party and venture forth! ADMIN MOD Shadowheart, Minthara, Karlach, Astarion Artwork Share Sort by: Best. If you skip the conflict in Act I, you can still get Minthara without losing the other two. A Baldur’s Gate 3 player manages to find a creative loophole that allows them to recruit Minthara to their party without having to first commit to an evil playthrough. For that to work, you have to start one of their romances in Act 1 and then make sure to pick flirting dialogue with Halsin during the course of the game (explicitly flirt at the grove party and ask about his love life when getting to know him dialogue becomes available). Poly romance with Karlach and Minthara? Act 2 - Spoilers this is possible, just got to act 2 and got Minthara. Recruit Karlach. Gale will potentially leave if you do not pass a persuasion roll. Reply reply Further more, if you allow Halsin and Minthara to stay in the same room then player would complain that they hate each other guts and it is make no sense at all. Just as the post says i have confirmed how to get both of them into your party and let me explain how. Advertisement . So you can have Karlach and Minthara in your No, knocking Minthara out is considered killing her too. When the game first came out, many people were reporting that Minthara So, i managed to get Minthara to join the party in act 2 without Karlach and Wyll leaving the forever. More like Minthara's comments, but she has complete commentary regarding Karlach and Wyll in their quest, meaning that yes, by game designs there are always chance Minthara can be in same party as Karlach and Wyll. Druids completed ritual, no sign of teiflings, hoping they got to baldurs gate. You only lose Karlach and Wyll if you go full evil and raid the Grove. I'm doing a second playthrough aiming to recruit Minthara but keep Karlach and Wyll on my team. I knocked her out, got all the indications from the journal and party banter saying she is dead, but she Gather your party and venture forth! Members Online • Alt-Profile8008 same goes for wizard and warlock to an extent(did do a dual class with it for a little before going back to full Paladin). Then immediately after the camp party with Minthara and the goblins, Karlach was back from the dead and initiated a dialog with me saying that she was leaving. But you cannot romance either Karlach (needs Dammon to survive into act 2) or Minthara (needs you to raid the grove personally which leads to first sex scene at the after-slaughter party in camp in act 1). Yes, you can recruit both Minthara and Halsin. The recruitment consequences line up with the pros and cons of romancing Minthara in BG3, which makes sense considering romancing her means committing to helping the Goblins against the Druids in the name of the Absolute. it is better to have her then not having her, BUt, there is a BUT don't trade her for Karlach content. 2. Here is how he did it: Yes, you can keep Minthara without losing Karlach or Wyll. I specifically caused the civil war in the grove (tiefling vs druid by stealing the idol without revealing korga) but ensured dammon, zevlor and Roland survived. Add them both to your party. So far I got told that there is no way if you side with Minthara, to save dammon, so the Quest line for Karlach is doomed. So instead, I just attacked without a word. I take long rest after the sceen is ended. Her wisdom score was done dirty because she clearly understands these characters in a way they do not themselves understand. Follow the caravan to the tower. Now do a Karlach run where you romance Minthara, and see the scene where Minthara actually cries about Karlach deciding You can have minthara, karlach, and will in the same party pretty easily. About Press Copyright Contact us Creators Advertise Developers Terms Privacy Policy & Safety How YouTube works Test new features NFL Sunday Ticket Press Copyright Minthara, evil, is an appealing addition to a party, but in EA we know we must carry out a heinous quest. It can still be an evil run it just won't be a raid the grove run. Is it possible to play as Karlach (evil Karlach) and pick up and romance Minthara after uniting with the goblins? Or is it impossible to get the Maybe you can romance both Halsin and Minthara at the same time. Share Add a Comment You can push the other companions to be far more evil than Minthara is once you free her, but sadly you are forced to go the evil path for Minthara. After that, I just finished everything else and went to act 2. If you want to get Mintara and Halsin at the same time, you will need to "free" Halsin and tell him to "stay". . Knocking out NPCs is the same as killing them for basically all instances outside of specific Gather your party and venture forth! I think it is possible to have Minthara, Karlach and Wyll together in you party in the vanilla game too, but you have to skip the druid grove questline and go to the Moonrise, where you can recruit Minthara (but then the tieflings will die). Astarion - Similar to shadowheart, he can pick a evil storyline, complementing the party roleplaying wise. But you can never have both Halsin and Minthara, as they are tied to opposite ends of the quest. If you fail, you will break; if your faith is This is my guide of how to romance Minthara and keep Wyll and Karlach in your party all while doing it. There is any mod to make Karlach ignore all the evil choices? like kill the tieflings and the druids in the grove and making her turn a blind eye hehehe. Minsc, Halsin, Minthara, Jaheira, and mystery final origin character as well! Same with Viconia and a couple other original characters. It's better to do this before meeting Minthara. Must have in evil party imo. Halsin is in the jail, but has dialogue as though he's in my camp. She’s a fantastic character, and I think she gets more depth more quickly (and overall, tbh) than poor Halsin. I haven't had them both at the same time so wouldn't know. Reply reply So for this playthrough I want to pick off the goblin camp people instead of just killing everyone at once like I did in my last playthrough. New. Minthara even has dialogue for curing the shadow curse, so that's good. Edit: unless you cheese the game, you will lose wyll, karlach and halsin. Get Minthara our via turning her invisible or whatever. If you take her out non Her having lines related to Wyll and Karlach makes sense because she can be in the same party as them. Q&A. I got into a romance with shadowheart in act one and got her to follow the path where she dyes her hair in act three (some of my sources claimed this was the only way she'd accept getting into any Pre-patch-5, having both Minthara and Karlach were not able to be in the same party, due to the genocide. Minthara sets a future rendezvous point in Act 2. Let Karlach and Wyll (if you want to keep him as well) steal the idol of Silvanus and they will immediately be attacked by the druids. That way you don't pick Yes, it is possible to have both Minthara and Karlach in your party at the same time in Baldur’s Gate 3. Controversial. Minthara you can recruit at the start of act 2 if you simply don't raid the grove and knock her which lets you keep Karlach keeping Karlach. Now, instead of taking on the 3 Goblin leaders tell him to wait for you in his cell. Gather your party and venture forth! Members Online • ProblemAlternative41 . First kill the goblin and the tiefling in the goblin camp in secret so become invisible and push the tiefling down the hole, let yourself be captured by the goblin, dont free yourself and someone will appear to help you, talk to minthara and say you know the place but cloud your mind, free halsing and make him acompany you but never get close to Necroing this post I guess, but can confirm after playing a run where I got Minthara as a companion after Moonrise Towers that being in a romance might not lock you out of Minthara's. Won't speak while in party or out of party, now can not ask her to leave party. 3. Minthara has less content than either Karlach or Wyll. This is an intended option by Larian and doesn't require this mod What if I killed Minthara at camp,raid,whatever Minthara is more an "oh shit" healer; she has Lay on Hands but it only has 3 charges at lvl 11-12. Have Withers store their souls. Halsin is a druid and you can't recruit him after destroying their camp. Laezel - Doesnt care what you do, so yeah, possible to include in the party. Karlach and Minthara all at the same time by essentially skipping the Same but the other way around, noone touches my alien goddess I’m already looking forward to my next playthrough, because I’ll pick Minthara as a companion. Can you keep Wyll and Karlach? By following specific steps, players can save Others have reported that there's banter between Minthara and Karlach, and that it may be possible to max out Karlach's favor before betraying the tieflings, allowing her to stay. Witness Minthara's inquisition. Then lead the goblin assault on the grove -Trick Minthara or the other leaders into turning on each other for supreme rule. Drow would not Before talking to Minthara, collect Karlach and Wyll. So, how will the other npc react? Will Karlach feel sympathy and empathy for her own kind? PLEASE READ THIS CAREFULLY: DO NOT SKIP. Both of them interest me to have them in my party but I don't know if there is something like Wyll will be angry if I don't try to kill her or something like that Yes, you can have Karlach, Wyll and Minthara in your party this way. Minthara, Wyll and Karlach. In the PFH it was shown that Jaheira does not give a damn about the grove, she does not mention it. I do like minthara and I enjoy having her in my party but its also very plain that a lot of the story is just kinda busted as a result. Minthara was still at goblin Gather your party and venture forth! Members Online • I'm doing an Evil/Dark Urge run and I met Minthara at the Goblin camp. Halsin and Minthara should not be possible and it is a bug probably. Open comment I'll mainly be swapping minthara in amd out, as well as doing the 2nd option for shadowhearts story. Bad news is I haven't gotten any ultimatium. Thanks for posting this. You rescue Halsin and tell him to stay where he is. You only recruit her in act 2 anyway if you just don't kill her. Can’t even remove her from my party. well it is understandable because she was added late in the development process as a companion. Maybe I should have replaced her with someone else. You can have Halsin and Minthara in the same play through and still have Wyll and Karlach Reply reply doing an evil dark urge run, after defeating ketheric minthara has a scene where she propositions me to be lovers (real ones, not just the post-grove sex) i say yes, figuring astarion wont mind, and then boom hes like “youre replacing me” and we break up. Old. Astarion and to a lesser extent Minthara have strong unique buffs and Minthara, Karlach/Wyll, and the Grove Question Act 1 - Spoilers So I already know the following scenarios from my own experience and YouTube: Formally side with goblins and clear Grove = Wyll and Karlach leave party or force you to kill them. Find Minthara in the dungeon, enter her mind, rescue her and kill her captors Foreword & Warnings. Side with no one (enter the Shadow-Cursed Lands without picking a side): Everyone except Halsin. She didn't, because she believed in her faith. I've seen cutscenes / screenshots of the 'evil' Act 1 party where you engage in Upon arriving in the Last Light I found the Tieflings. You do not need to choose between them or sacrifice one for the What did you do with the grove? Did you save Halsin or the refugees? Or did you out Kagha? And is Dammon stil alive for Karlach's questline? Thank you for the post, been Just don’t do the grove vs goblins quest at all, and all three of them will be in your party together. As far as I’m aware you can’t. laoa hrum qrxfww fdthu unoiz muqaqpp qaln qovktcq tsrx rdshifa